Sometimes fighting fraud means stepping back from the individual claim and joining the dots. As part of International Fraud Awareness Week, we take a look inside Linked & Organised Fraud operations to reveal how seemingly separate claims became part of a much bigger picture.
The initial claim
A commercial van driver was reported to have been approached by an individual and offered cash to crash his vehicle into a parked car. Whilst the driver had refused the offer, the team commenced enquiries looking at recent claims from drivers within the same depot, narrowing to those with multiple incidents over a short period and where the claimant had gone on to utilise repair services within similar locations.
The red flag
Based on the volume of claims identified together with the initial report, it was clear this was a sophisticated organised fraud group coordinating financial payouts.
The connection
Not only could claims be linked via similar circumstances and locus, the team also secured evidence from a handwriting expert and forensic engineer demonstrating a clear pattern of behaviour and intricate web of deceit.
The strategy
33 claims were identified in total, and five claims proceeded to trial with each relying on the similar fact evidence identified across the Operation, along with a witness statement which ran to a total of 110 pages, providing evidence of the connections.
The result
The defendant was successful in their action against those involved in the fraud, with the court awarding damages in the sum £285,610 across the five cases. The court also took the extra step of awarding exemplary damages across all five cases totalling £224,000. Costs were awarded on an indemnity basis with orders for costs in the sum of £390,000 to be paid within 14 days.
The initial claim
The defendant received a claim for personal injury, vehicle damage and credit hire charges following a minor road traffic collision in a supermarket car park, which involved one of their customers. The claim was initially investigated following concerns over the extent of damage and claim value compared to the minor incident reported by their driver.
The red flag
Following investigations the defendant noted the claimant’s address linked to several other accidents which involved the same credit hire organisation. More detailed enquiries were made, and it became apparent there were numerous accidents in car parks within a narrow locus, all of which appeared to involve relatively minor impacts but resulted in extensive vehicle damage and credit hire charges. The most striking similarity was the demographic of the victims, all of whom were retired individuals travelling alone or with their partners, either completing their shopping or attending a doctor’s appointment.
The connection
Final investigations found significant similar fact evidence across 27 claims. This included accident circumstances and location, individuals and addresses involved, plus repeat companies utilised across the claims.
The strategy
Several claims were litigated by the claimants at the point investigations concluded. As a result, applications were made for claims to be case managed together where timetables allowed. A similar fact defence, disclosure and witness statement were relied on across all claims, and counter claims in deceit were issued.
The result
All claims were successfully defeated securing savings in excess of £150,000, and counter claims were also successful with exemplary damages awarded. In addition to this, proceedings for contempt of court were issued against key orchestrators which resulted in four immediate custodial sentences.
The initial claim
Following a relatively minor road traffic collision, a claim was intimated for whiplash injuries, tinnitus and hearing loss.
The red flag
Given the relatively minor nature of the incident, and the lack of force involved in the collision, concerns arose when a claim for permanent hearing loss was presented from an individual who had previously been in good health. On review, there were no objective indictors to pre-empt such a claim. There had not been sufficient force to cause the airbags to deploy, occupancy displacement was likely to have been minimal and there was minor structural damage to the vehicle.
The connection
Initial concern about the claim for extensive injuries was justified when investigations identified that the medical expert had consistently produced reports for almost identical injuries in numerous other claims. These injuries were reported irrespective of the accident severity and appeared to take little, if any, notice of the claimant’s individual medical history.
The strategy
In order to demonstrate the issues as a whole, several claims were case managed together. An appropriately redacted bundle was prepared, supported by a similar fact statement detailing the pattern of behaviour and consistent prognoses being provided by the expert, irrespective of collision force and individual medical characteristics.
The result
The operation to date has secured savings in excess of £4m. The evidence of one of the target ENT experts has been formally rejected by the court, which doubted his expertise and was not convinced he had satisfied his duties as an expert witness under CPR 35 when giving evidence to the court. That expert is also the subject of an ongoing GMC investigation, and we have assisted by providing information and copy of the judgments rejecting his evidence. The claimant’s solicitors have begun to discard the evidence of the target experts, either reducing claims for alleged otological injuries or abandoning them entirely. This operation is ultimately delivering a change in claims behaviour and a reduction in future reserves for insurers.

Designed to elevate the policyholder experience and empower handlers, ClaimPilot transforms the claims journey with state-of-the-art AI, streamlined processes and reduced operational bottlenecks – all in one powerful platform.
