• Home / Insight / Court approach to issue-based costs orders in high-value personal injury claims

    Court approach to issue-based costs orders in high-value personal injury claims

    18/11/2026

    JBX (Suing by DBX, his Mother and Litigation Friend) v Frimley Health NHS Foundation Trust [2026] EWHC 2525 (KB)

    Overview

    This costs judgment follows the substantive trial in a high-value clinical negligence claim concerning the claimant's future care and accommodation needs, which we previously covered in detail here. While the claimant recovered damages exceeding £4.3 million together with substantial periodical payments, he failed on the principal issue at trial, namely his proposed domiciliary care and accommodation regime. The court was then required to determine whether that failure justified a departure from the usual rule that costs follow the event.

    Decision

    The court held that the claimant remained the successful party overall because he obtained a substantial damages award. However, given that the trust had succeeded on the principal issue at trial, the claimant's recoverable costs should be reduced.

    The court ordered that the defendant pay 85% of the claimant's costs on the standard basis, to be assessed if not agreed.

    Future care and accommodation

    The central dispute concerned whether the claimant's reasonable needs were best met through a domiciliary care package proposed by the claimant or through residential care arrangements advocated by the defendant.

    The defendant succeeded on this issue. The judge recognised that the majority of the evidence, expert opinion and trial time was devoted to future care and accommodation.

    Overall success

    Despite losing the principal battleground, the claimant remained the successful party because he recovered substantial damages and succeeded on the disputed lost years claim. The court reaffirmed that successful claimants in complex personal injury and clinical negligence litigation frequently lose individual issues without losing their entitlement to costs.

    Absence of Part 36 offers

    A significant feature of the case was that neither party had made a Part 36 offer. The trust relied on late settlement proposals made shortly before trial, but the court held that Part 36 remained the mechanism through which a defendant should ordinarily seek costs protection.

    The judge relied upon Fox v Foundation Piling Ltd and noted that the trust was effectively seeking some of the benefits associated with Part 36 despite never making a Part 36 offer.

    Key principles

    1. Costs generally follow the event, and a claimant who obtains substantial damages will normally remain the successful party even if unsuccessful on important subsidiary issues.
    2. Success on a major issue can justify a reduction in costs but will not necessarily displace the general rule altogether.
    3. Issue-based costs orders remain exceptional and fact-sensitive. The court favoured a broad-brush percentage reduction rather than attempting to identify costs attributable to individual issues.
    4. Defendants should protect their position through Part 36 offers. Failure to do so may significantly weaken arguments for substantial costs sanctions even where the defendant succeeds on the main issue at trial.
    5. Alleged litigation misconduct will carry limited weight unless it can be shown to have generated meaningful additional costs.

    Practical takeaways

    • Success on the principal issue at trial does not necessarily make the defendant the successful party for costs purposes.
    • Defendants should consider making early and realistic Part 36 offers, particularly where they dispute only a limited number of heads of loss or a specific future care proposal.
    • Courts continue to be reluctant to undertake detailed issue-by-issue costs analysis in catastrophic injury and clinical negligence litigation, preferring percentage reductions where appropriate.
    • Where a claimant's position is supported by credible expert evidence, failure at trial will not necessarily be regarded as unreasonable conduct justifying severe costs consequences.

    The judgment is a useful reminder that, in catastrophic injury and clinical negligence litigation, the courts remain focused on identifying the overall successful party. While success on a dominant issue may justify a reduction in costs, defendants who have not deployed Part 36 effectively may find it difficult to secure substantial costs protection, even where they prevail on the principal dispute at trial.

    Jamie McCabe
    Author

    Jamie McCabe
    Partner
    Complex & Catastrophic Loss

    Contact

    Related Insights

    money - notes and coins

    High Court orders disclosure of claimant's bank statements in £12m future care claim

    rehab centre map

    Complex Injury Care & Rehab SIG launches new practical resource for handlers

    car crash 4

    There are no outlaws in negligence: Keoghs complex injury successfully argues causative potency in High Court case

    ASHE Data Release 2026

    ASHE Data Release 2026

    Stay informed with Keoghs

    Sign-up

    Our Expertise

    Introducing ClaimPilot

    Designed to elevate the policyholder experience and empower handlers, ClaimPilot transforms the claims journey with state-of-the-art AI, streamlined processes and reduced operational bottlenecks – all in one powerful platform.

    Learn more

    Green arrow on cloud